Skip to content

Philosophy of mind

Philosophical inquiry into consciousness, subjectivity, and the mind-body relationship.

State of the evidence

Synthesized

Synthesized from 25 studies in the library · AI-generated, grounded in the abstracts below

Found by searching the library for Philosophy of mind, consciousness studies, hard problem, phenomenology, then ranked by relevance.

Research on philosophy of mind, particularly regarding consciousness and selfhood, is largely theoretical and argumentative, with no empirical consensus. Studies propose various frameworks—such as the temporo-spatial theory of consciousness, enactive affordance-based models, and critiques of panpsychism—but direct empirical evidence is limited to phenomenological descriptions of altered states (e.g., ego dissolution, meditation) and theoretical debates about animal sentience. The main caveat is that most evidence is conceptual rather than experimental, and the hard problem of consciousness remains unresolved.

Evidence by study

Direction is which way each study's own result points, not our rating of the study.

What the directions mean
Supports:
the study found the intervention worked, or its hypothesis held.
Opposes:
it found the opposite, no benefit or a harm.
No effect:
no significant difference either way.
Mixed:
effects in both directions within the same study.
Unclear:
the abstract does not report a direction.

Proposes that psychosis in schizophrenia can be understood as a state of aberrant salience, linking dopamine dysregulation to the formation of delusions and hallucinations.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Proposes that psychosis arises from aberrant assignment of novelty and salience, and that antipsychotics attenuate this aberrant salience rather than eradicating symptoms, with improvement evident in the first few days.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that Shusterman's somaesthetics provides a philosophical approach to overcoming Cartesian mind-body dualism by emphasizing mindful bodily awareness as integral to human experience and self-improvement.

review article

Reviews evidence that psychedelic states can be characterized by three primary dimensions—oceanic boundlessness, anxious ego-dissolution, and visionary restructuralization—and are influenced by both pharmacological and non-pharmacological factors.

review

Reviews controlled laboratory studies showing that psilocybin can occasion complete mystical experiences in the majority of people studied under double-blind conditions, with enduring positive effects on mood, attitudes, and behavior.

review

Proposes that four temporo-spatial mechanisms of brain activity—nestedness, alignment, expansion, and globalization—correspond to different dimensions of consciousness.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Finds that the lived experience of psychosis progresses through distinct stages characterized by core existential themes, from loss of common sense in early phases to grieving and struggling with acceptance in later stages.

co-written bottom-up review

Proposes an enactive, affordance-based model with four aspects (field of affordances, self-experience, relating to the world, existential stance) to capture the phenomenological changes in OCD patients treated with deep brain stimulation.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that drug-induced ego dissolution disrupts subpersonal processes underlying the minimal or embodied self, consistent with Bayesian models of phenomenal selfhood, and challenges theories that consciousness always involves self-awareness.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Reviews Varela's framework integrating biological autonomy, embodiment, and neurophenomenology to explain consciousness as an emergent property of circular causality in living systems.

review

Finds that prior experiences suggestive of transcendence of death are more common among near-death experiencers than among control populations, but prior experiences suggestive of extrasensory phenomena are less common, and subsequent changes in attitudes are more common than in subjects with other psychic experiences.

retrospective study Sample size: 78

Finds a syndrome of ten visual disturbances, lasting up to five years in half of the sample, treatable with benzodiazepines, exacerbated by phenothiazines, and precipitated most commonly by emergence into darkness, with sensitivity to LSD flashbacks dividing the sample into three discrete subgroups.

observational cohort Sample size: 123

Finds that micro-phenomenological interviews can produce rigorous descriptions of meditative experience that are valuable for understanding, practicing, and teaching meditation.

pilot project

Finds that seven categories of experience (internal/external, time, location, self, agency, ownership, and first-person perspective) change as the sense of boundaries dissolves, while the touching/touched structure and bodily feelings remain even when boundaries disappear.

qualitative case study Sample size: 1

Finds that hypnotic depth and spontaneous phenomena after neutral hypnosis vary by hypnotizability level and are related to global functional connectivity and EEG frequency band activity.

observational cohort Sample size: 37

Argues that Donald Griffin's case for animal consciousness rested on three evidentiary avenues: neural correlates, behavioral versatility, and animal communication as a window into animal minds, and that he faced opposition from scientific assumptions rooted in Cartesian views and parsimony concerns.

historical analysis

Argues that teleost fish brains can support sentience without requiring pallium-neocortex homology, advocating a functionalist approach, and that human neural correlates offer a starting point but fish-specific research is needed.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that Reber's claim of sentience as inherent in biological forms rests on unexamined assumptions about continuity and gradual accretion of mental faculties, which are not empirically justified, and that the hard problem remains unresolved.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that Reber's axiom is not supported by evolutionary biology, and that consciousness is linked to behavioral flexibility rather than cell wall flexibility, proposing that determining which species can experience welfare is a more pressing issue than solving the hard problem.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Opposes

Argues that Reber's theory does not solve the hard problem of consciousness, as it fails to explain why conscious states feel the way they do, though studying simple minds may be methodologically useful.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that behavioral grounds can justify consciousness ascription to non-human animals, including insects, and that Klein & Barron's perspective is reconcilable with global workspace theory's core claims.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that the cortex is not essential for all forms of consciousness in vertebrates and that subjective experience can be supported by midbrain structures, as exemplified by insects, and proposes that functional neurobiological analyses combined with behavioral studies are needed.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that invertebrates merit moral consideration because sentience is not limited to large-brained animals, and that humans should be less human-centered in their ethical treatment of animals.

theoretical or philosophical paper

Argues that Key's denial of fish pain is based on inconsistent reasoning and outdated views on brain evolution, and that current evidence supports the possibility of pain in fish.

commentary

Argues that the term 'consciousness' is scientifically misleading due to its diverse uses and checkered history, despite popular enthusiasm, while acknowledging advances in cephalopod cognition research.

commentary

Points of agreement

  • Several theoretical papers propose that consciousness and selfhood are grounded in embodied, dynamical processes rather than a dualistic mind-body split.
  • Phenomenological studies of altered states (psychedelics, meditation, hypnosis, psychosis) converge on the idea that the sense of self is not monolithic and can be disrupted or dissolved.
  • Debates on animal consciousness converge on the need for functionalist approaches and behavioral evidence rather than strict neuroanatomical homology.

Conflicts

  • There is disagreement on whether sentience can be attributed to simple organisms: some argue for continuity and inherent sentience, while others argue that such claims are not empirically justified.
  • The role of the cortex in consciousness is contested: some argue it is not essential, while others imply it is necessary for pain or consciousness.
  • The term 'consciousness' itself is debated as scientifically misleading versus a useful concept.

Gaps

  • Most evidence is theoretical or phenomenological; empirical studies are limited to small samples or specific populations.
  • Long-term durability of altered states and their implications for consciousness are not well studied.
  • The hard problem of consciousness remains unresolved, and no empirical test has been proposed to settle it.
  • Comparative studies across species are needed to clarify which neural circuits support different conscious capacities.
Browse these studies in the library
How we analyze this

This synthesis reads the 15 most-cited and 10 most recent studies whose primary subject is Philosophy of mind, up to 25 in all. The most-cited set anchors the established evidence, and the recent set surfaces work that is too new to have gathered citations yet.

A study qualifies only when Philosophy of mind or a known alias appears in its title or keywords, so broad reviews that mention it only in passing are left out. Each study is read from its abstract, strongest evidence first, and the summary reports the direction of the results along with any conflicts and gaps.

Latest monthly recap: August 2026 →

8,027 articles · 3,337 from the last two years · 1,082,868 participants across 1,553 studies reporting sample size

Common study designs

review 640 qualitative study 296 experimental study 184 observational cohort 327 theoretical or philosophical paper 4257

The Formal Structure of Phenomenology Qualia, Manifestation, and Selector-Access Regimes

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) September 13, 2026 Nova Spivack

This paper develops the formal phenomenology layer that extends the operational boundary theory of unified agency established in Paper 73 . Paper 73 characterized the structural conditions under which a system forms a unified self-indexing adjudicative regime (O-SIAM). The present paper asks what additional formal structure is required for manifestation, qualia, subjectivity, and self-presence...

From Three Axioms to the Hard Problem of Consciousness: A Constructive Response via the Information-Level Unidirectional Constraint English Version

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) September 13, 2026 Jiaping Wang

Mainstream theories of consciousness largely address what Chalmers calls the easy problems and do not explain, from first principles, why a complete third-person description cannot recover first-person experience. Starting from three axioms (finite resources, non-equilibrium persistence, and discrete input) and arguing by eliminative convergence, this paper forms an Information Capacity Frame...

Exploring the Origins of Subjectivity and Awareness with the Twin Cognitive Cycle (TCC): the Hard Problem of Consciousness

September 13, 2026 Qi Zhang

Subjectivity and awareness are widely regarded as core properties of consciousness, and explaining their nature remains a major challenge in consciousness research. While many existing theories provide predominantly qualitative accounts, the development of quantitative modeling may bridge the explanatory gap. This study expands the Twin Cognitive Cycle (TCC) model by focusing on quantifying the...

It from I: Internal Phenomenology

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) September 13, 2026 C. G. Trahern

In this fourth paper of the "It from I" series, we shift our analytical focus from the external emergence of spacetime, General Relativity and Cosmology, and the Standard Model of particles and fields to the internal phenomenology of the Observer. Building upon the Anti-Zeno Navigation Model established in Paper II, we treat subjective consciousness not as an emergent computational output, but...

Qualia and the Semantic Ledger: A Formal Dissolution of the Hard Problem Paper 55 of the NEMS Suite

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) September 13, 2026 Nova Spivack

The hard problem of consciousness asks how syntax or computation alone could generate qualitative experience. Papers 51–54 established that no final internal self-theory exists, no syntactic structure can exhaust semantics, and no observer can self-exhaust . The present paper proves that any qualitative content known by a subject must be represented in the semantic ledger; once represented,...

Epoché and Protoexistence: Toward a Genetic Phenomenology of Experiential Emergence.

Integrative psychological & behavioral science September 12, 2026 Cristóbal Pacheco, Pablo Fossa

This theoretical-conceptual essay reconsiders epoché in qualitative phenomenological research and its relation to experiential emergence. Rather than a one-time technique of bracketing, epoché is conceptualized as a sustained discipline of epistemic suspension, attentional reorientation, and phenomenological restraint. On this basis, protoexistence is reformulated as a heuristic for incomplete...

The Missing Counterpart - Chalmers and Illumanesimo: The Hard Problem of Composite Consciousness and the Direction of Inquiry

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) September 11, 2026 Roberto Mucciarini

This essay develops a methodological proposal complementary to the research programme outlined in CEFA – Proposta di indagine. Taking the hard problem of consciousness as its starting point, it distinguishes subjective experience, the data through which we study it, and hypotheses concerning its origin. An examination of selected neuroscientific studies clarifies why the limitations of...

Does the MEM Model Explain the "Hard Problem" of Phenomenal Consciousness?

Qeios September 10, 2026 Wiesław L Galus

This article addresses David Chalmers's hard problem of consciousness by asking why information processing is accompanied by a subjective 'what it is like'. Its point of departure is the distinction between intelligence and phenomenal consciousness: the achievements of contemporary artificial intelligence show that reasoning, planning, language, and the accurate description of emotions do not...

Mysticism: Process and Event? From Causality to Motivation in the Phenomenology of Mystical Experience According to Edith Stein

Religions September 10, 2026 Gwendolyn Araya Gómez

(1) Background: This article situates Edith Stein within the 20th-century debate on the nature of mystical experience, framing it as a philosophical problem concerning the relationship between divine initiative and human freedom, and aims to reassess dominant developmental interpretations of mysticism. It argues that, alongside theological models such as that of Réginald Garrigou-Lagrange,...

Reactive and Dissociative Psychosis Re-visited: Trauma, Identity, and the Phenomenology of Collapse

Mental Health: Global Challenges Journal September 10, 2026 Mykhaylo Pustovoyt, Ivan Romash, Yuliia Medynska et al.

To read the full-text Open Access article and download the PDFs, please visit our Issue portal at Paradigm (Walter de Gruyter): https://reference-global.com/article/10.56508/mhgcj.v9i1.368 Introduction: Diagnostic differentiation between dissociative, reactive, and psychotic disorders remains conceptually and clinically challenging due to overlapping phenomenology and insufficiently specified...

Clinical trials

All Philosophy of mind trials →