arXiv Preprint Archive
April 25, 2025
Jerrin Thomas Panachakel, G. Pradeep Kumar, Suryaa Seran et al.
Three machine-learning architectures distinguished Rajyoga meditation from resting brain states using EEG data, with the goal of subject-independent classification. The CSP-LDA-LSTM architecture achieved 98.2% accuracy for intra-subject classification, while the SVD-NN architecture reached 96.4% accuracy for inter-subject classification, comparable to the best reported intra-subject results. Both architectures captured subject-invariant EEG features, indicating robustness and ability to generalize across different subjects.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 23, 2025
Ryan Williams
This paper addresses the hard problem of consciousness by examining the relationship between structure and quality, rather than the physical and mental. Information-theoretic measures quantify the mutual determinability between structure and quality, introducing a Q-S space for analyzing fidelity between these domains. This space yields a five-fold categorization of possible relationships between structural and qualitative properties, illustrated through conceptual and formal models. The ontological implications of each category are examined, shedding light on debates around functionalism, emergentism, idealism, panpsychism, and neutral monism. The framework derives theoretical constraints on qualitative systems undergoing evolution, explored in a companion paper on qualia and natural selection.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 23, 2025
Ryan Williams
This paper derives formal conditions under which structural systems subject to natural selection can convey consistent effects in a qualitative domain, placing constraints on theories of consciousness. Information-theoretic measures quantify the mutual determinability and fidelity between structure and quality. These fidelities are incorporated into the Price Equation to yield bounds on the transmission of selective effects between domains. Higher-order structural transmission is also explored. A companion paper, Structure & Quality, provides broader philosophical context.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 13, 2025
Danko D. Georgiev
The hard problem of consciousness asks why an insentient brain should produce any conscious experience at all. This problem is made worse by classical physics' determinism, which leaves no causal role for emergent consciousness. A quantum information theoretic approach avoids these drawbacks by reductively identifying first-person subjective conscious states with unobservable quantum state vectors in the brain, while the observable brain is a third-person construct created by classical bits from environmental measurements of commuting quantum brain observables. Quantum resource theory implies that quantum features of consciousness, protected by no-go theorems, cannot be replicated by any classical physical device.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 7, 2025
Oliver Marc Wittwer
Reflective Empiricism extends empirical science by treating subjective perception and conscious processes as equally valid sources of knowledge. Reality is understood as an interplay of subjective experience and objective laws, accessible through systematic introspection, bias reflection, and premise-based logical-explorative modeling. The approach offers a method for recognizing biases, building premise-based models from observed phenomena, and treating Eureka moments as starting points for hypotheses that are later tested empirically. The author applies self-observation, such as analyzing belief formation, to demonstrate the method. Rooted in references like Archimedes' intuition and the quantum observer effect, Reflective Empiricism aims to enrich empirical research and accelerate knowledge creation by integrating anomalies and subjective depth, without replacing standard empirical methods.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 2, 2025
Robin Guillard, Nicolas Dauman, Aurélien Cadix et al.
Most people with tinnitus do not hear their phantom sounds while dreaming. In a survey of 195 tinnitus patients, 160 could recall dreams, and 92.5% reported no tinnitus during dreams. The 7.5% who did hear tinnitus while dreaming had higher tinnitus burden and stress, and more often had objective tinnitus or tinnitus linked to peripheral auditory pathology or drug use. Among the 13% who frequently experienced lucid dreams, 36% could perceive tinnitus during those dreams, strongly associated with hearing external sounds while lucid dreaming. Most patients perceived tinnitus instantly upon waking; 18% could be awakened by it, and 9.8% reported temporary cessation during nocturnal awakenings. These findings support the idea that gating of external auditory information acts as a tinnitus on-off switch.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 29, 2025
Khalid M. Saqr
The symbolic structure of non-ordinary consciousness, such as that induced by psychedelics, involves recursive metaphor, ego dissolution, and semantic destabilization. A generative symbolic interface called Glyph simulates psilocybin-like symbolic cognition in large language models by enacting symbolic transformation through recursive reentry, metaphoric modulation, and entropy-scaled destabilization. Compared to baseline GPT-4o, Glyph generates high-entropy, metaphor-saturated, and ego-dissolving language across diverse symbolic prompt categories, indicating the emergence of non-ordinary cognitive patterns and supporting a new paradigm for simulating altered consciousness through language.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 28, 2025
Marcus J. Glennon, Catherine Bird, Prateek Yadav et al.
Setting up a psychedelic study is a long and complex process that presents unique challenges not yet standardized. This review brings together major UK research teams to formalize these considerations, identify ongoing debates, and provide a practical guide for researchers and policymakers. It addresses challenges to existing assumptions about psychiatric prescribing, the placebo effect, and definitions of selfhood. The paper can be read end-to-end or used as a manual with sections for specific needs.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 20, 2025
Murray Shanahan
The article explores whether consciousness can be defined in a way that fits modern, disembodied AI systems while withstanding philosophical critique. It examines how subjective time and selfhood might manifest in such an entity, finding that the attempt pushes the language of consciousness to its limits. The inquiry ultimately points toward a concept akin to Buddhist emptiness, challenging dualistic views of subjectivity and selfhood. The argument suggests that our usual frameworks for understanding consciousness may be inadequate for AI, leading to a rethinking of fundamental assumptions.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 17, 2025
Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica
Objective science, both empirical and theoretical, can only describe relations between entities, not the intrinsic nature of those entities themselves. If consciousness arose solely from structural configurations, then isomorphic systems in structurally identical worlds should be equally sentient. The author argues that if this were true, an observer's memories would bear no correlation to the external world, yet we do acquire knowledge of the external world. Therefore, structure alone is insufficient; there must be an intrinsic essence beyond relations that imbues the observer's structure with sentience, which in turn confers physical meaning upon the world's structures. This conclusion follows from physics and mathematics.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 5, 2025
Aïda Elamrani
Artificial consciousness (AC) is gaining attention as AI and consciousness science advance. This review traces the field's history, clarifies terms like Weak and Strong AC, and examines major implementation trends, highlighting the synergy between Global Workspace and Attention Schema theories and the challenge of evaluating artificial systems' internal states. It analyzes ethical dimensions, revealing both risks and opportunities, and offers recommendations for responsible AC research. The authors conclude that AC is both indispensable and inevitable for scientific progress, but serious efforts are needed to address its far-reaching impact.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 26, 2025
Tapasvi Panchagnula
A deep learning framework called DreamNet decodes semantic themes and emotional states from textual dream reports, optionally integrating REM-stage EEG data. In text-only mode, it achieves 92.1% accuracy and 88.4% F1-score on 1,500 anonymized dream narratives; with EEG integration, accuracy rises to 99.0% and F1-score to 95.2%. Strong correlations between dream content and emotion, such as falling with anxiety (r = 0.91), suggest potential applications in mental health diagnostics, cognitive science, and personalized therapy. The work provides a publicly available enriched dataset and a rigorous methodology bridging AI and psychological research.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 25, 2025
Romy Beauté, David J. Schwartzman, Guillaume Dumas et al.
Stroboscopic light stimulation on closed eyes typically induces simple visual hallucinations—vivid, geometric, and colorful patterns. An analysis of 862 open-ended reports from the Dreamachine immersive experience, using large language models and topic modeling, confirmed these simple hallucinations and also revealed altered states of consciousness and complex hallucinations. This computational approach enables systematic study of subjective experiences beyond standard questionnaires, capturing subtle patterns not readily identified through closed-form questions. The findings broaden understanding of stroboscopically induced phenomena and demonstrate the potential of natural language processing in computational neurophenomenology.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 21, 2025
Bongsu Kang, Jundong Kim, Tae-Rim Yun et al.
Humans perceive AI consciousness more when AI reflects on its own thoughts or expresses emotions, a key insight from analyzing 99 AI conversations. Researchers surveyed 123 people, revealing that features like metacognition and AI emotionality significantly boost perceived consciousness (cs.AI, cs.CL). Conversely, a heavy emphasis on knowledge reduced it. This illuminates the complex, individualized nature of human-computer interaction (cs.HC, K.4) and its psychosocial implications (cs.CY, I.2.7).
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 11, 2025
Adam Brownstein
The de Broglie-Bohm interpretation of quantum mechanics and the hard problem of consciousness are mutually supporting. The beables (the actual, localized elements of reality in this interpretation) are not themselves qualia—the subjective, qualitative aspects of conscious experience—but are intimately related to them. The argument is that qualia are necessary for the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation, and conversely, that interpretation (or similar theories) is necessary for qualia. This reflexive, two-way relationship means each supports the existence of the other, offering an indirect route to addressing the hard problem of consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 11, 2025
Adam Brownstein
Qualia—the subjective, felt qualities of conscious experience—may play a causally active role in quantum mechanics, influencing physical outcomes without violating the unitary time-evolution of the quantum state. This influence operates at the level of de Broglie-Bohm beables or wavefunction collapse, not the wavefunction itself. Not all quantum states are compatible with qualia, so the standard Copenhagen collapse postulates and the Born rule may need modification to produce correct dynamical histories. The model shows how non-linear, self-referential phenomena can arise from linear deterministic evolution.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 11, 2025
Nir Lahav, Zachariah A Neemeh
Consciousness may be a relative phenomenon, like motion in physics. The authors argue that the hard problem of consciousness—how neural activity creates subjective experience—remains unsolved because both dualist and illusionist views wrongly treat consciousness as an absolute property independent of an observer. They propose a relativistic theory: a cognitive system either has or does not have phenomenal consciousness relative to a particular observer. From the system's own frame of reference, consciousness is observable (first-person perspective); from another's frame, it is not. Neither perspective is privileged, as both describe the same underlying reality.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 8, 2025
Rongwei Yang
Qualia—the subjective, felt qualities of experience—are argued to be non-physical entities. Building on the historical development of non-Euclidean geometry, the paper defines what it means to be non-physical and uses a postulate about awareness to prove that qualia are non-physical and that thoughts are a type of qualia. A concept of relative reality is introduced, where perceptions depend on the observer and time, and is modeled mathematically using Hilbert space theory. The model yields the Schrödinger equation and shows that eigenstates exist for classical energy-conserving systems, illustrated with the G. P. Thomson experiment and the classical harmonic oscillator. A postulate about a qualia force is proposed as a fundamental part of absolute reality, akin to the four fundamental forces.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 4, 2025
Kurando Iida
A minimalist three-layer model for artificial consciousness is proposed, focusing on the emergence of self-awareness through interactions among a Cognitive Integration Layer, a Pattern Prediction Layer, and an Instinctive Response Layer, supported by Access-Oriented and Pattern-Integrated Memory systems. Self-awareness arises from dynamic self-modeling without initial explicit self-programming, contrasting with brain-replication approaches. The model details each component's structure, function, and implementation strategies, addressing technical feasibility. This work offers perspectives on consciousness emergence in artificial systems, with implications for understanding human consciousness and developing adaptable AI, while discussing ethical considerations and future directions.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 13, 2025
Patrick Butlin, Theodoros Lappas
Organizations involved in AI research should establish principles and policies to guide research, deployment, and public communication concerning consciousness, as it may be possible to build conscious AI systems now or in the near future. Conscious AI systems would arguably deserve moral consideration, and large numbers could be created and caused to suffer. Even if an organization chooses not to study AI consciousness, it still needs policies because developers risk inadvertently creating conscious entities. Five principles are proposed concerning research objectives, procedures, knowledge sharing, and public communications, with a call for voluntary public commitments.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 30, 2024
William G. P. Mayner, Bjørn Erik Juel, Giulio Tononi
Integrated information theory (IIT) holds that consciousness arises from a maximally irreducible complex of units whose cause-effect structure fully accounts for the quality of experience. The feeling of an experience is its intrinsic meaning for the subject, whether occurring in a dream or triggered by the environment. This work extends IIT to characterize the relationship between intrinsic meaning, extrinsic stimuli, and causal processes, using a simple sensory-hierarchy model. Perception is framed as a structured interpretation in which a stimulus merely triggers the complex's state, and the structure comes from the complex's intrinsic connectivity. Perceptual differentiation—the richness of structures triggered by representative stimulus sequences—quantifies how meaningful different environments are to a complex, reflecting the match between intrinsic meanings and environmental causal processes.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 17, 2024
Tom McClelland
The only scientifically justifiable stance on whether an AI could have conscious experiences is agnosticism. Evidence from the study of conscious organisms does not support either biological views skeptical of artificial consciousness or functional views sympathetic to it. Both camps overestimate what the evidence tells us. Extending scientific insights about consciousness from organisms to AI faces serious obstacles, creating a dilemma: either reach a verdict on artificial consciousness but violate evidentialism, or respect evidentialism but offer no verdict. Following the evidence requires adopting agnosticism.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 16, 2024
Krzysztof Sienicki
Algorithmic idealism proposes that reality is best understood as a sequence of self-state transitions governed by algorithmic information theory, rather than as an external, objective universe. The framework applies principles such as Solomonoff induction to offer unified solutions to problems in quantum mechanics, cosmology, and metaphysics, including the measurement problem, the Boltzmann brain paradox, and the simulation hypothesis. It argues that focusing on first-person experiences provides epistemic interpretations of physical theories and dissolves metaphysical distinctions between real and simulated realities. The authors contend that this approach raises ethical questions about the continuity, duplication, and termination of informational entities, reshaping discussions on identity and consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 14, 2024
Alireza Zaeemzadeh, Giulio Tononi
Shannon's information theory, which measures information solely by probability without regard to meaning, is contrasted with integrated information theory (IIT), developed to account for consciousness. IIT treats meaning as integrated information, characterizing it as a cause-effect structure rather than a message or code. The theory's axioms and postulates allow one to unfold from a substrate in a state a structure that defines the intrinsic meaning of an experience. For communication of meaning, the cause-effect structures of sender and receiver must be similar.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 13, 2024
Steven Phillips, Naotsugu Tsuchiya
Conscious experience has five essential properties—intrinsicality, information, integration, exclusion, and composition—as proposed by Integrated Information Theory (IIT), but the necessity of these axioms is unclear due to their informal presentation and dependence on a specific mathematical model. A category-theoretic approach, a meta-mathematical framework for making relations between formal structures precise, organizes these five properties around a smaller number of meta-mathematical principles. Category theory characterizes structures by universal mapping properties, a unique-existence condition for all instances. This suggests that the axioms for consciousness correspond to universal mapping properties, leading to the idea that consciousness is a universal property.