arXiv Preprint Archive
January 26, 2023
Johannes Kleiner, Tim A. Ludwig
A definition is proposed for what a 'mathematical structure of conscious experience' is, linking abstract mathematical entities to the concrete aspects of conscious experience. This definition complements existing approaches that study quality spaces, qualia spaces, or phenomenal spaces. It offers a general method for identifying and investigating structures of conscious experience and may serve as a unifying framework for diverse approaches across fields. The work aims to provide a basis for developing a common formal language to study consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 17, 2023
V. A. Aksyuk
A proposed extension to predictive processing theory adds online, single-example structure learning through hierarchical binding of unpredicted inferences, enabling fast compositional learning and explaining access consciousness. The system learns new causes by connecting novel combinations of perceptions, forming working memories that become short- and long-term declarative memories retrievable by associative recall. Bound representations are unified yet differentiated, maintained by selective attention and globally available. The model explains contrast and masking manipulations, postdictive perceptual integration, and other paradigm cases. 'Phenomenal conscious experience' arises as the learning system transparently models its own functioning, producing perceptual illusions underlying the meta-problem of consciousness. The proposal unifies feature binding, recurrent processing, predictive processing, and global workspace theories.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 12, 2023
Charles Johnstone, Prashant S. Alegaonkar
Consciousness shapes how reality, including ourselves, is perceived and defines personal identity through experience. It is central to unresolved problems in physics, such as observation and the measurement problem, yet its nature, brain mechanisms, and universal location remain unknown, making it a key scientific challenge. This review examines physical processes linked to consciousness, including signal transmission in the brain, chains of events, quantum phenomena, and integrated information. It also discusses the roles of matter structure, fields, and universality. The authors propose further studies to improve understanding of consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 10, 2023
Mahendra Samarawickrama
Consciousness is a sequential process of awareness that focuses on one piece of information at a time, experiencing causation that underpins time while interacting with matter and energy to form reality. Patterns in consciousness emerge from regularities in nature—physical, biological, chemical, mental, and social—and evolve into cultural constructs, systems, and values. Responsible AI design should be attuned to these evolved ethical and moral values through consciousness, requiring self-learning AI that is aware of time perception and human ethics.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 4, 2023
Larissa Albantakis, Robert Prentner, Ian T. Durham
Integrated information theory (IIT), originally a framework for characterizing consciousness through causal information, is extended to finite-dimensional quantum systems such as quantum logic gates. The authors translate a measure of intrinsic information into a density matrix formulation and adapt conditional independence to account for quantum entanglement. This quantum extension of IIT may reveal internal structure of composite quantum states and operators that standard information-theoretic analysis misses. The work aims to inform debates about the relationship among consciousness, causation, and physics across classical and quantum domains.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 18, 2022
Alexander Gorsky
Consciousness may be characterized by an order parameter analogous to the Page curve used in black hole physics. The entanglement between the brain's state and the time series of neuronal firing, along with the non-orthogonality of functional connectomes, are central to this proposal. The conjecture draws on the recent resolution of the black hole information paradox to suggest a measure for the state of consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
December 8, 2022
Eduardo C. Garrido-Merchán, Javier Sánchez-Cañizares
Integrated information theory (IIT) proposes a quantitative measure, Φ, to estimate whether a physical system is conscious, its degree of consciousness, and the complexity of its experienced qualia. The theory models a physical system as a probabilistic causal graph of interconnected elements with input-output functions. This paper presents a random search algorithm that optimizes Φ to investigate how graph structure changes with increasing numbers of nodes to achieve higher Φ. The authors also discuss why more complex black-box search methods like Bayesian optimization or metaheuristics face difficulties for this problem and suggest future research directions to improve the search for maximal Φ.
arXiv Preprint Archive
November 22, 2022
Martin Korth
Natural intelligence differs from current artificial intelligence not just in degree but in kind, being tied to consciousness, intentionality, qualia, understanding, and aesthetic or ethical judgment that go beyond rule-based or correlation-based processing. Psychological research shows natural intelligence ranges from unconscious processes to focused reasoning, and from embodied cognition to true agency and creativity, operating on 'bits of meaning' rather than data. The author proposes an alternative view of natural intelligence as information processing plus 'bundle pushing', illustrates how this can shortcut processing, and suggests initial ideas for neurobiological and information-theoretic experiments.
arXiv Preprint Archive
October 26, 2022
Hana Hebishima, Mina Arakaki, Chikako Dozono et al.
A mathematical model of consciousness and will is proposed, starting with a neural-network simulation that confirms inverted qualia—subjective experiences that differ between individuals, making qualia unreliable as indicators of consciousness. To address this, a probability space and random variable are introduced over a set of qualia, defining a public language for events. Consciousness and will are modeled as future actions randomly selected from a comparison between external event recognition and past episodic memory, with actual action recognition constituting the occurrence of consciousness. A basic formula is derived, and the proposal is compared with prior philosophical discussions.
arXiv Preprint Archive
September 29, 2022
Xian Wang, Xiaoyu Mo, Mingming Fan et al.
A systematic review of 19 papers from IEEE and ACM databases examined how virtual reality technology is used in meditation research. The review found no existing guidelines or comprehensive reviews on conducting such studies. It analyzed meditation types, design considerations, and VR technologies employed in the eligible studies, and identified research opportunities and challenges for future work in this area.
arXiv Preprint Archive
September 26, 2022
Manvi Jain, C. M. Markan
Ten minutes of meditation improves executive control of attention in people who do not regularly meditate. Twenty-six novice participants completed a Stroop task, which measures cognitive control by introducing conflict, before and after a brief meditation intervention. Behavioral responses showed faster reaction times and greater accuracy after meditation. Neurophysiological recordings revealed more efficient allocation of attentional resources, with increases in positive ERP components (P200, P300) and a decrease in the inhibitory component (N200). The findings suggest that even short meditation sessions can positively impact attention in a non-meditating population.
arXiv Preprint Archive
September 21, 2022
Ankur Betageri
Quality of life can be compared across cultures when assessed at the sensory and perceptual level, rather than through metrics focused solely on material means or freedom. The author argues that a more meaningful approach evaluates an individual's ability to organize their context by perceiving positive constellations of environmental factors and achieving valuable acts and states of being. Because felt quality of life derives from an indivisible structure of a milieu, it cannot be regarded as merely subjective. Using the example of how different frequencies of light are perceived as color, the author demonstrates that the human cognitive apparatus apprehends different scales of quantity as degrees of quality.
arXiv Preprint Archive
September 16, 2022
Fay Dowker
The paper develops Rafael D. Sorkin's proposal that the birth of spacetime atoms in causal set quantum gravity, a partially ordered process, provides an objective physical correlate of the perception of time passing. It argues that a fully objective, external picture of this birth process is impossible because the order of birth is partial. The author proposes that live experience in causal set theory is an internal view of this objective process, where events that are neural correlates of consciousness occur. What animates a neural correlate of consciousness is the same process that animates the whole universe: the unceasing, partially ordered birth of spacetime atoms.
arXiv Preprint Archive
August 24, 2022
Martin Korth
A properly formulated idealism can offer an alternative view of the mind/matter gap and shed light on open questions in the scientific materialist worldview. To investigate this, idealism needs a model integrating modern science that allows a mathematically consistent reinterpretation of the physical world as a limiting case of a world that is both material and non-material, making idealist considerations accessible to scientific investigation. The author explains what 'scientifically tenable' idealism means, formulates the emanation problem (which replaces the interaction problem for idealism), briefly summarizes available elements from philosophical literature, sketches design questions for constructing such models, and presents a first model for a scientifically tenable objective idealism.
arXiv Preprint Archive
August 3, 2022
Eduardo C. Garrido-Merchán, Sara Lumbreras
Phenomenal consciousness and computational intelligence are independent properties, so machines that solve problems like humans do are not necessarily conscious. The authors argue that problem-solving ability does not imply consciousness, and that machines may develop higher computational intelligence than humans without possessing phenomenal consciousness. They propose an objective measure of computational intelligence and examine its distribution across humans, animals, and machines, while treating phenomenal consciousness as a dichotomous variable. The independence of these traits has critical social implications, particularly regarding rights: if rights were granted based on problem-solving capacity, machines could be seen as having more rights than people with disabilities, which the authors reject.
arXiv Preprint Archive
July 28, 2022
Aline Viol, Gandhi M. Viswanathan, Oleksandra Soldatkina et al.
The physical basis of consciousness remains an open question. Using complex network theory, the study compared resting-state functional brain networks of individuals before and after ingesting the psychedelic brew Ayahuasca. The researchers calculated pairwise information parity to quantify statistical symmetries between brain region connectivity across the entire network. They detected an increase in average information parity in brain networks under psychedelic influence. Notably, information parity between regions of the limbic system and frontal cortex was consistently higher for all individuals while under the influence.
arXiv Preprint Archive
July 17, 2022
John Rushby, Daniel Sanchez
A series of eight workshops held in 2017 assessed the possibility of machine consciousness and its implications. The report summarizes discussions on brain structure and function, theories of consciousness, attempts to construct conscious machines, detection and measurement of consciousness, potential emergence of conscious technology, methods for controlling such technology, and ethical considerations. An appendix outlines each workshop's topics and talk abstracts. The report was refreshed in 2022 after a Google engineer claimed LaMDA was sentient, to provide background for the debate, with footnotes highlighting recent developments while noting the technical points remain valid.
arXiv Preprint Archive
July 11, 2022
Matthieu Gilson, Enzo Tagliazucchi, Rodrigo Cofré
Consciousness depends on complex, irreversible brain dynamics that produce entropy. By fitting a statistical model to fMRI data and calculating entropy production, researchers found a monotonic relationship: entropy production decreases as people move from wakefulness to deep sleep. This suggests that entropy production is a robust signature of consciousness, linking conscious states to the thermodynamic activity of the brain.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 28, 2022
Anton Arkhipov
Consciousness in physical systems arises from non-separability of degrees of freedom, with the amount of consciousness determined by the extent of this non-separability and the number of degrees of freedom involved. Non-interacting and feedforward systems have zero consciousness, while most interacting particle systems have low non-separability and consciousness. Brain circuits, with high complexity and weak but tightly coordinated interactions, support high non-separability and thus high consciousness. The hypothesis applies to both classical and quantum cases, and the Wigner function formalism (which becomes the Liouville density function in the classical limit) offers a framework for characterizing non-separability. The hypothesis aligns with Integrated Information Theory and Orchestrated Objective Reduction Theory and may help reconcile them.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 10, 2022
Vadim Weinstein, Basak Sakcak, Steven M. Lavalle
This work identifies five core principles of enactivist cognitive science from the literature and builds a mathematical framework for modeling cognitive systems—both artificial and natural—that adheres to those principles. The framework avoids attributing contentful symbolic representations to agents and treats brain, body, and environment as an inseparable whole. The central concept is a sensorimotor system, a type of transition system. The authors introduce the notion of sufficiency as a foundational concept, prove a uniqueness theorem about minimal sufficient refinements (which correspond to optimal attunement of an organism to its environment), and relate sufficiency to existing concepts like sufficient history information spaces. The work aims to make enactivist ideas accessible to computer scientists, AI researchers, and psychologists, while providing philosophers a mathematical tool.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 4, 2022
Giulio Tononi, Larissa Albantakis, Melanie Boly et al.
Integrated information theory (IIT) implies that free will exists in a fundamental sense. IIT defines consciousness as a maximum of cause-effect power in the brain, with the structure of that power determining how experiences feel. According to this theory, humans have true alternatives, make true decisions, and are the true cause of their willed actions, bearing true responsibility. The argument depends on an intrinsic powers ontology: only intrinsic entities truly exist and can cause effects, and consciousness qualifies as such an entity.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 14, 2022
Paul Pu Liang
A multimodal inner language called Brainish, combining words, images, audio, and sensations, is proposed as essential for machine consciousness. Building on the Conscious Turing Machine (CTM) model, the authors define Brainish's syntax and semantics and operationalize it through multimodal AI: unimodal encoders segment data, a coordinated representation space composes features for holistic meaning, and decoders produce predictions or raw data. A simple implementation of Brainish is evaluated on multimodal prediction and retrieval tasks using real-world image, text, and audio datasets. The authors argue that such an inner language is crucial for communication and coordination in achieving machine consciousness and intelligence.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 11, 2022
Jacob Jolij
Panpsychism, the view that consciousness is a fundamental feature of reality rather than a product of brain activity, offers an elegant solution to the mind-body problem but is often dismissed as untestable. This paper presents a panpsychist model that treats consciousness as a higher physical dimension, a speculative idea that nonetheless yields empirically testable predictions. While the model is likely wrong, its main purpose is to demonstrate how metaphysical theories of consciousness can be specified to allow scientific testing, thereby bridging the gap between philosophy and empirical science.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 29, 2022
Jared Edward Reser
The article presents a framework for simulating human-like thought in computers by modeling the dynamics of mammalian working memory, which includes sustained firing (seconds-long information preservation) and synaptic potentiation (minutes-to-hours preservation). It proposes that machine learning implementations should continuously and iteratively update these memory stores, with each state preserving a proportion of coactive representations from the prior state, causing gradual and incremental evolution of concepts in working memory. Transitions between states occur as persistent activity spreads activation through a hierarchical network, searching long-term memory for associative additions to the global workspace. This iterative updating is presented as an information processing strategy, a model of working memory, a theory of consciousness, and an algorithm for designing artificial intelligence.
arXiv Preprint Archive
March 24, 2022
Arthur Juliani, Kai Arulkumaran, Shuntaro Sasai et al.
The authors examine three contemporary theories of conscious function—Global Workspace Theory, Information Generation Theory, and Attention Schema Theory—and find that each relates conscious function to some aspect of domain-general intelligence in humans. They then observe that state-of-the-art deep learning methods have begun incorporating key aspects of these theories, though they remain far from demonstrating general intelligence. Using mental time travel in humans as a motivating example, the authors propose combining insights from all three theories into a single unified model. Such artificial agents would possess greater general intelligence and align more closely with current understanding of consciousness's functional role, making this a promising near-term AI research goal.