arXiv Preprint Archive
August 18, 2020
Jerome A Feldman
Subjective experience (consciousness) remains a scientific mystery because objective, third-person science cannot fully capture first-person, private experience. Evolutionary evidence suggests that subjective experience first appeared in vertebrates, and its neural substrate is largely preserved in mammals and humans. While the bodily aspects of perception and emotion are understood, the subjective component is not. Converging evidence from theoretical, experimental, and computational studies provides strong constraints and suggests future research directions. Despite limitations, progress has been made in understanding the role of subjective experience in the success of prostheses.
arXiv Preprint Archive
August 12, 2020
Maryam Alimardani, Linda Kemmeren, Kazuki Okumura et al.
A robot assistant guided mindfulness meditation while recording brain activity via EEG. Two groups of people interacted with the robot, one group meditating and the other not. Unlike prior meditation studies, the robot-guided practice did not change frontal alpha or theta brain waves. However, the meditation group showed stronger right-sided occipital gamma activity, linked to sensory awareness and open monitoring. Participants reported improved mood after interacting with the robot, regardless of whether they meditated. The findings suggest EEG can detect mindful states during robot-guided meditation, but the brain changes may differ from traditional meditation. This is the first report of EEG changes during robot-guided mindfulness practice.
arXiv Preprint Archive
August 6, 2020
Rodrigo Cofré, Rubén Herzog, Pedro A. M. Mediano et al.
Altered states of consciousness, such as those experienced during dreaming or meditation, offer a way to study how large-scale brain activity relates to different subjective experiences. This paper advocates a research program that combines bottom-up generative models of whole-brain activity, based on known properties of neural tissue, with top-down signatures proposed by theories of consciousness. The authors define altered states, discuss relevant brain-activity signatures, and introduce whole-brain models to explore the mechanisms behind these states. They argue that systematically investigating altered states through bottom-up modeling can clarify the biophysical, informational, and dynamical foundations of consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
July 31, 2020
Camilo Miguel Signorelli, Quanlong Wang, Ilyas Khan
Consciousness is treated as fundamental and characterized by other-dependence, meaning conscious processes are defined by their relations to one another. A mathematical framework using compact closed categories is introduced, where morphisms represent conscious processes composed of generators specified by their interrelations. This compositional model may help avoid the hard problem of consciousness and address the combination problem of conscious experiences.
arXiv Preprint Archive
July 16, 2020
Camile Bahi
Depression is the world's leading cause of disability, yet classical antidepressants offer limited relief. Ketamine and psychedelics have shown promise and received Breakthrough Therapy designation. Their precise mechanisms remain unclear, but shared features include promoting structural, functional, and behavioral plasticity and increasing Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) via mTOR activation. This review connects pharmacological pathways of 5-HT2AR agonists and NMDA antagonists to neurobiological and psychological responses. It suggests that BDNF-driven plasticity alters connectivity in high-level cognitive networks like the Default Mode Network, fostering lasting psychological flexibility. Verifying these hypotheses could guide development of safer antidepressants and biomarkers for treatment response.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 16, 2020
Kai Lukoff, Ulrik Lyngs, Stefania Gueorguieva et al.
A review of 370 mindfulness apps on Google Play shows they primarily present mindfulness as a tool for relaxation and stress reduction. Interviews with 15 U.S. mindfulness teachers from therapeutic, Buddhist, and Yogic traditions reveal concern that this narrow framing neglects mindfulness's full potential. The teachers' experiences suggest design implications for linking apps with deeper contemplative practices, such as cultivating compassion. The findings emphasize the importance of coherence in design: the metaphors and mechanisms of a technology should align with the underlying principles it follows.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 12, 2020
Jake R. Hanson, Sara I. Walker
A concrete electronic-circuit example shows that Integrated Information Theory (IIT) is simultaneously falsified at one level of analysis (finite-state automaton) and unfalsifiable at another (combinatorial state automaton). The authors argue that to avoid being unfalsifiable or already falsified, scientific theories of consciousness must be invariant under changes that leave the inference procedure fixed at a given level in a computational hierarchy.
arXiv Preprint Archive
June 9, 2020
Indu P. Bodala, Nikhil Churamani, Hatice Gunes
Social robots can deliver mindfulness sessions via teleoperation, where a human coach controls the robot's upper body and head movements in real time and sees through its camera. Over five weeks, participants who interacted with the teleoperated robot coach reported positive responses for all sessions, similar to those who interacted with a human coach. However, ratings for the robot coach's motion and conversation changed over time, while human coach ratings remained consistently high. Participants' personality traits, specifically conscientiousness and neuroticism, influenced their perceptions of the robot coach.
arXiv Preprint Archive
May 28, 2020
Natesh Ganesh
A formal model of generating experimental data and inferring conscious experiences, introduced by Kleiner and Hoel, suggests that many theories of consciousness are pre-falsified if inference reports are valid. This reply expands that model to distinguish different types of variation. Using examples from neural networks, state machines, and Turing machines, it proves that substitutions do not exist for a broad class of Level-1 functionalist theories, making them immune to the substitution argument and indicating that not all leading theories are fundamentally flawed.
arXiv Preprint Archive
May 25, 2020
U. J. Mohrhoff
Reality is relative to consciousness or experience, not a single mind-independent world. Drawing from QBism, Kant, Bohr, Schrödinger, the Upanishads, and Sri Aurobindo, the ontology proposes different poises of consciousness, including a universal consciousness where all individuals are aspects of one whole. This framework resolves philosophical issues in science arising from reifying instruments or calculational tools and from ignoring the human experiential context of science. It also addresses problems in the philosophy of mind, such as intentionality and Husserl's paradox of the mutual inclusion of self and world.
arXiv Preprint Archive
May 22, 2020
Jonathan J. Mize
The problem of logical omniscience—the assumption that agents know all logical consequences of their beliefs—has prompted many proposed solutions, but most merely tweak standard Kripke semantics without engaging with psychological mechanisms. This paper introduces a psychologically grounded approach called PQG logic, built on fundamental units of percepts, qualia, and cognitions. From these building blocks, it develops a novel semantics for belief, knowledge, psychological necessity, and possibility. The framework aims to address logical omniscience and to better understand the psychological-logical nature of belief and knowledge.
arXiv Preprint Archive
May 7, 2020
John Realpe-Gómez
A formal model of scientists doing science produces dynamics analogous to quantum mechanics, where the analogue of Planck's constant relates to the process of observation. The model suggests that certain aspects of subjective experience—embodiment and the capacity to observe from an intrinsic perspective—cannot be eliminated from science. This leads to a relational view: every experience has a physical correlate, and every physical phenomenon is an experience for someone. The work may help bridge the explanatory gap between subjective experience and physical phenomena and hints at non-dual modes of experience.
arXiv Preprint Archive
May 4, 2020
Didier Pinault
A single low dose of ketamine, an NMDA receptor antagonist, transiently reduces sleep spindles and delta oscillations in the thalamocortical systems of rats, while amplifying gamma-frequency oscillations and shifting neuronal firing from burst to single-spike mode. The antipsychotic clozapine prevents these effects. The findings support the hypothesis that reduced NMDA receptor function contributes to the spindle deficit observed in schizophrenia.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 9, 2020
Hongzhi Wang, Bozhou Chen, Yueyang Xu et al.
This paper presents ConsciousControlFlow (CCF), a prototype system designed to demonstrate conscious Artificial Intelligence. The system is built on a computational model of consciousness and a hierarchy of needs. CCF is shown to support typical scenarios that illustrate the behaviors and mental activities of a conscious AI. The authors propose that CCF serves as a useful tool for demonstrating machine consciousness and for assisting in the study of human behavior.
arXiv Preprint Archive
April 7, 2020
Johannes Kleiner, Erik Hoel
Falsification, a cornerstone of scientific testing, is especially problematic for theories of consciousness. In the standard experimental setup, a theory's predicted experience (based on brain data) is compared with an inferred experience (based on report or behavior). If inference and prediction are independent, any minimally informative theory is automatically falsified—a dilemma for many current theories that rely on report to infer conscious experience. If inference and prediction are strictly dependent, the theory becomes unfalsifiable. The paper explores potential ways out of this dilemma, highlighting a fundamental challenge for empirical testing in consciousness research.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 18, 2020
Bartosz Jura
Conscious experience appears to change constantly, yet any content must last for a nonzero duration to be perceived, creating a fundamental conflict. This work argues that this temporal aspect is the most basic property of consciousness, likely inherent to any conceivable form. Taking this perspective offers a way to relate consciousness directly to neural plasticity mechanisms of learning and memory. The authors propose a "synaptic clock" as a content-specific neural substrate of consciousness, where moments of subjective time have different durations proportional to the time units of these clocks, varying across brain regions and species. The work argues for a dynamic view of consciousness, where change is its only dimension.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 11, 2020
Jae-Geun Yoon, Minji Lee
People with low performance in motor imagery brain-computer interfaces (MI-BCIs) show a 23% performance gap compared to high performers, and a specific brain connectivity pattern during resting-state EEG—from the right lateral parietal to the left lateral parietal region—correlates negatively with MI performance (r = -0.37). These results suggest that resting-state effective connectivity may help explain why some individuals cannot effectively use MI-BCIs, a phenomenon known as BCI-illiteracy, and could guide alternative approaches tailored to the user.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 6, 2020
Marco Alberto Javarone, Olivia Gosseries, Daniele Marinazzo et al.
A mean-field model inspired by Integrated Information Theory and Tegmark's representation of consciousness analyzes order-disorder phase transitions on Curie-Weiss models generated from EEG signals recorded on healthy individuals undergoing deep sedation. A machine learning tool classifies mental states using critical temperatures computed from these models. The method discriminates between states of awareness and deep sedation. A state space representing the path between mental states is identified, with dimensions corresponding to critical temperatures over different EEG frequency bands. The method may have clinical applications.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 3, 2020
David R. Glowacki, Mark D. Wonnacott, Rachel Freire et al.
A virtual reality journey called 'Isness' can induce mystical-type experiences (MTEs) comparable to those from high doses of psilocybin or LSD. In a study of 57 participants, responses to a standard psychedelic experience questionnaire showed MTE levels similar to those in double-blind clinical trials. The authors argue that both psychedelic drugs and virtual reality belong to a broader spectrum of psychedelic technologies. Within a supportive setting, VR phenomenology can create conditions for MTEs that participants find insightful and meaningful.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 3, 2020
David R. Glowacki, Mark D. Wonnacott, Rachel Freire et al.
Virtual reality can induce profound mystical experiences similar to those triggered by psychedelic substances, without the need for drugs. A groundbreaking human-computer interaction (cs.HC) experiment showed that carefully designed VR environments can create transformative group experiences where participants perceive themselves as pure energy, fostering deep feelings of connection and transcendence. Data from 57 participants revealed emotional responses matching those reported in clinical studies of psilocybin and LSD.
arXiv Preprint Archive
February 2, 2020
Eduardo C. Garrido-Merchán, Martin Molina
Consciousness in machines may be achieved by combining recent advances in deep learning and generative models with symbolic reasoning within a cognitive architecture inspired by the global workspace theory. The proposed architecture assumes that consciousness emerges in machines that exhibit cognitive processes and conscious behavior. It integrates multiple modules, each using state-of-the-art AI models, whose correlated activities are coordinated through a global workspace. The authors provide detailed explanations of the models involved and how they communicate, aiming to create a system that could give rise to machine consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 31, 2020
T. N. Palmer
Human creativity and consciousness may be unintended byproducts of the brain's extraordinary energy efficiency. Creativity arises from a synergy between two cognitive modes: one where energy spreads across a large neural network, making neurons susceptible to thermal noise, and another where energy focuses on a small subset for deterministic operation. Consciousness is defined as awareness of nearby counterfactual worlds in state space, arising from an interplay between memories and quantum physical mechanisms in neural ion channels, again for energy efficiency. This definition offers a novel explanation for why quantum entanglement feels counter-intuitive.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 28, 2020
Don N. Page
The fact that first-person conscious perceptions contain many bits of information strongly suggests they are produced nonlocally by the effects of many atoms, possibly via nonlocal quantum operators. If these operators act back on the quantum state of atoms, they could cause signals to propagate faster than light, violating the usual causality of local quantum field theory. Although there is no direct evidence yet that such nonlocal operators associated with psycho-physical parallelism act back on the quantum state, it is not totally implausible. In principle, the resulting superluminal propagation might be observable by sending signals across brain regions that lead to conscious perceptions.
arXiv Preprint Archive
January 26, 2020
Ulrike Barthelmeß, Ulrich Furbach, Claudia Schon
A first-order logic reasoning system paired with a large knowledge base can function as an artificial consciousness system. Drawing on Tononi's Information Integration Theory and Baars' Global Workspace Theory, the paper applies these frameworks to the Hyper reasoning system using ConceptNet for commonsense and cognitive reasoning. The system demonstrates the ability to perform conscious mind wandering, suggesting that such architectures can exhibit key features of consciousness.
arXiv Preprint Archive
November 26, 2019
Danko D. Georgiev
Consciousness consists of inner, subjective, private experiences that cannot be measured by physical devices or communicated as classical bits. Classical physics cannot explain how such unobservable, incommunicable experiences could arise from physical neurons. Thought experiments like inverted qualia and the knowledge argument illustrate this challenge but do not prove consciousness is nonphysical or that introspective reports are unreliable. Modern quantum physics offers a resolution: unobservable quantum state vectors define what physically exists, while quantum operators define what can be observed. Identifying consciousness with unobservable quantum information in brain states allows quantum information theorems to resolve paradoxes of privacy and explains how the observable brain is constructed from classical bits extracted upon measurement, bound by Holevo's theorem.