Skip to content

Husserl, representationalism, and the theory of phenomenal intentionality

Chang Liu

European Journal of Philosophy June 21, 2023 DOI: 10.1111/ejop.12881 (opens in new tab)

Study at a glance

AI-extracted from the abstract
Characteristics Theoretical or philosophical paper Peer reviewed
Citations 4
Key points Argues that Husserl's phenomenology, while opposed to strong representationalism, is compatible with weak representationalism because Husserl holds an essential connection between noematic senses and hyletic data; further argues that Husserl's position is consistent with the phenomenal intentionality theory, since all non-phenomenal intentional states ultimately rest on phenomenal intentional states and sensual perceptions.

Abstract

Abstract Representationalism is a philosophical position which reduces all phenomenal conscious states to intentional states. However, starting from the phenomenal consciousness, the phenomenal intentionality theory provides an explanation of all sorts of intentionality. Against Michael Shim's interpretation, I argue that, although Hussserl's phenomenology is certainly considered as an antipode of strong representationalism, Husserl does not stand in opposition the weak representationalists, because Husserl maintains an essential connection between the senses of noemata and the hyletic data. In addition, Husserl's phenomenology is also consistent with the phenomenal theory of intentionality. According to him, statically and genetically, all non‐phenomenal intentional states take a recourse to phenomenal intentional states and eventually to sensual perceptions.

Citations in the library

Explore topics