Skip to content

A Portrait of Spiritual Trauma in the Tradition of the Descent of Salih Among Women in Siulak, Kerinci

Mina Zahara, Rahyu Zami

YINYANG Jurnal Studi Islam Gender dan Anak September 1, 2026 DOI: 10.24090/yinyang.v21i2.16376 (opens in new tab)

Study at a glance

AI-extracted from the abstract
Characteristics Qualitative study Peer reviewed
Population Women in Siulak District, Kerinci, who became Balian Salih and women who had previously refused the call
Key findings Argues that the Penurunan Salih tradition often manifests as "supernatural coercion," producing spiritual trauma and psychosomatic disorders ranging from chronic headaches to disturbances of consciousness. Contends that pressure from traditional structures, including the Ninik Mamak, and the legitimacy of rituals leave women with no choice but to accept the Balian Salih role, and that formal integration with Islamic symbols (syncretism) leaves residual trauma indicating the subordination of women's bodies.

Abstract

This article is grounded in the mystical traditions experienced by women—both those who accept and those who reject them—in the Siulak region of Kerinci. The aim of this study is to examine the dimensions of mysticism within the Penurunan Salih tradition in Siulak District, Kerinci, with a focus on the psychological and sociological impacts on women who are chosen by ancestral spirits. Unlike previous studies that tend to describe rituals as cultural heritage, this research highlights the tension between customary authority and women’s individual agency. This study employs a phenomenological approach to explore the subjects’ experiences in depth. Data were collected through participant observation and in-depth interviews with women who became Balian Salih as well as those who had previously refused the call. Analysis was conducted using Pierre Bourdieu’s theory of Symbolic Violence and Marlene Winell’s STR. The findings reveal that the Penurunan Salih tradition often manifests as a form of “supernatural coercion,” leading to spiritual trauma and psychosomatic disorders, ranging from chronic headaches to disturbances of consciousness (insanity). Pressure from traditional structures through the role of the Ninik Mamak and the legitimacy of rituals leaves women with no choice but to accept the role of Balian Salih. Although this tradition is formally integrated with Islamic symbols (syncretism), residual trauma indicates the subordination of women’s bodies as

Explore topics