A significant proportion of adolescents continue to experience impairing psychiatric symptoms even after receiving existing mental health services. The authors propose that the benefit-to-risk calculation supports trialing classic serotonergic psychedelics (e.g., psilocybin) and empathogenic compounds (e.g., MDMA) in combination with psychotherapy among select adolescents aged 16 to 17 years. They specifically recommend testing these treatments in adolescents with treatment-resistant psychiatric disorders or disorders that align with the current adult evidence base, such as those with FDA breakthrough designation for psilocybin in major depressive disorder or MDMA in posttraumatic stress disorder.
A trial is planned to gather initial evidence on whether combining psilocybin with cognitive behavioral therapy is feasible, safe, acceptable, and has psychosocial benefits for people with major depressive disorder. The results will guide larger randomized trials to test this combined treatment's effects and explore how it might work through changes in thinking and emotion. The trial is registered at ClinicalTrials.gov with ID NCT05227612.
Pairing psilocybin with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is acceptable, feasible, and associated with substantial improvements in major depressive disorder. In a small open-label trial, 16 adults with at least moderately severe depression received two psilocybin doses (10 mg and 25 mg) and 12 CBT sessions over four months. All participants completed the 7-month study with no serious adverse events. By treatment end, 13 of 16 showed at least 25% improvement in depressive symptoms, and 9 had fully remitted. Gains in depressive symptoms and psychosocial functioning were sustained three months later, with large effect sizes (Hedges' g = 1.9–2.7). Improvements correlated with better emotion regulation and more positive cognitive schemas.
Two patients in a clinical trial of psilocybin-assisted cognitive behavioral therapy for major depressive disorder had markedly different outcomes. One patient experienced powerful, beneficial effects from psilocybin that led to immediate and sustained antidepressant effects over seven months. The other patient faced significant challenges with psilocybin and reported minimal to no antidepressant effects after the drug sessions. The clinicians' experiences treating both patients are also presented. The authors theorize about future research needed to understand how psilocybin can produce the greatest psychiatric benefit, what patient conditions enable or inhibit benefit, and what psychosocial environment best facilitates psilocybin therapy.
The authors respond to two letters about their earlier commentary on psychedelic-assisted therapy trials for 16- to 17-year-olds. They reaffirm that ethical and methodologically rigorous research is essential across psychedelic medicine and that conducting such research in adolescents is sensible and worthwhile. They also acknowledge risks from extrapolating adult efficacy data and from off-label prescribing practices common in child and adolescent psychiatry, inviting further dialogue on the subject.