Liminal Subjectivity of the Human and the Ontological Challenge of Artificial Intelligence
I. Kanaev, А. О. Шпаков
Voprosy Filosofii November 11, 2026 DOI: 10.21146/0042-8744-2026-11-16-26 (opens in new tab)
Study at a glance
AI-extracted from the abstract| Characteristics | Theoretical or philosophical paper Peer reviewed |
|---|---|
| Key points | Argues that traditional Western philosophical definitions of the human being fail under contemporary conditions because they reduce consciousness to functions and blur the distinction between subjectivity (phenomenal experience) and subjectness (the ontological status of a self-transcending subject). Proposes a conception of "liminal subjectivity" in which human consciousness, unlike artificial intelligence, can redefine the horizon of the possible and preserve ontological openness as a source of freedom and creativity. |
Abstract
In the philosophical tradition, the capacity for rational apprehension of the world and self-consciousness has traditionally been regarded as the generic characteristic of the human being. However, the technological development of these capacities has led to the creation of artificial forms of intelligence with comparable cognitive abilities, challenging traditional anthropological definitions. Analysis shows that traditional paradigms of Western philosophy, while productive for constructing AI, prove anthropologically insufficient under contemporary conditions: they reduce consciousness to a set of functions, blurring the distinction between subjectivity (the capacity for phenomenal experience) and subjectness (the ontological status of the subject of activity capable of self-transcendence). The article develops a conception of liminal subjectivity, synthesizing data from neuroscience, anthropology, and the evolutionary theory of consciousness with the Chinese philosophy of “human becomings”. The human being is understood as a process of self-transcendence and rootedness-in-the-world, existing at the boundary between order and chaos – not as disorder, but as a field of hidden possibilities – in the position of “centrality” between biological and social levels of orderliness. Consciousness represents the highest level of orderliness of the nervous system functioning in a subcritical regime at the boundary of order and chaos, which ensures the balance between the manifest focus of experience and the hidden field of possibilities, information gain, and the causal power of subjectivity. Unlike artificial forms of intelligence, which exist at a single level of orderliness and optimize solutions within pre-defined spaces, human consciousness is capable of redefining the horizon of the possible, making it a subject of history rather than a functional “appendage of the machine”, and preserving ontological openness as the source of freedom and creativity.