Neuropsychiatric phenomena in the medieval text Cantigas de Santa Maria.
Francisco de Assis Aquino Gondim, Sarah H Griesbach, Florian P Thomas
Neurology May 1, 2015 DOI: 10.1212/wnl.0000000000001554 (opens in new tab)
Study at a glance
AI-extracted from the abstract| Characteristics | Historical analysis Peer reviewed |
|---|---|
| Population | 427 canticles of the Cantigas de Santa Maria, including 353 narrative miracle stories |
| Keywords | Humans Nervous system diseases Mental disorders History, medieval Music Religion and medicine Portugal Spain Poetry as topic |
| Key points | The authors report that the Cantigas de Santa Maria contain early descriptions of neuropsychiatric conditions, identifying 279 medically relevant facts across 187 canticles and possible neuropsychiatric conditions in 98 canticles. They argue these accounts show how medieval societies combined rational and irrational approaches to explain events, while acknowledging limits from retrospective interpretation. |
Abstract
Objective: To discuss the neuropsychiatric phenomena described in Cantigas de Santa Maria (Canticles of St. Mary [CSM]).
Background: CSM is a collection of 427 canticles composed in Galician-Portuguese between 1252 and 1284 at the Court of King Alfonso X the Wise of Spain (1221-1284). The canticles (of which 9 are repeated) include devotional and liturgical poems and 353 narrative stories consisting mainly of depictions of Marian miracles. Most are set to music and many are illustrated.
Methods: We reviewed the canticles for description of miracles and other neuropsychiatric phenomena. Two neurologists reached a consensus about the descriptions.
Results: Of the 353 miracles, 279 medically relevant facts (from 187 canticles) and 25 instances of resurrection were reported. Possible neuropsychiatric conditions were described in 98 canticles. Physicians were mentioned in 16 narratives. The most common neurologic conditions detailed were blindness (n = 17), dystonia, weakness, and deformities (n = 20). Other common conditions included psychosis (n = 15), speech disorder/deaf-mutism (n = 12), infections (n = 15), sexual dysfunction/infertility/obstetrical-gynecologic issues (n = 18), head trauma (n = 5), ergotism/St. Anthony's fire (n = 7), and others. There were 9 instances of prodromic mystical experiences/hallucinations heralding death.
Conclusions: While limited by retrospection and interpretation of neuropsychiatric phenomena in the medieval context, these short accounts are among the first descriptions of neuropsychiatric conditions in early Portuguese/Galician. They reflect how medieval societies used rational and irrational approaches to understand occurrences in their lives.