Dualism, Materialism, and the relationship between the brain and the mind in experiencing pain.

Pain from an injury requires both long-term potentiation (LTP) in a subset of pyramidal neurons in the anterior cingulate cortex and the creation of electromagnetic waves in the surrounding area. LTP sensitizes synaptic transmission and changes the phenotype of the neurons, sustaining the waves and pain. The waves disseminate information about pain to distant brain areas and can influence LTP induction. According to leading theories, the waves communicate with the mind, where painfulness is experienced, supporting the view that the material brain and immaterial mind are separate. This challenges the idea that consciousness can be duplicated by mimicking brain activities.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Characterizing the relationship between the brain and the mind is essential, both for understanding how we experience sensations and for attempts to create machine-based artificial intelligence. Materialists argue that the brain and the mind are both physical/material in nature whereas Cartesian dualists posit that the brain is material, the mind is non-material, and that they are separate. Recent investigations into the mechanisms responsible for pain can resolve this issue. Pain from an injury requires both the induction of a long-term potentiation (LTP) in a subset of pyramidal neurons in the anterior cingulate cortex and the creation of electromagnetic waves in the surrounding area. The LTP sensitizes synaptic transmission and, by activating enzyme cascades, changes the phenotype of the pyramidal neurons. The changes sustain the generation of the waves and the pain. The waves rapidly disseminate information about the pain to distant areas of the brain and studies using Transcranial Stimulation show that EM waves can influence the induction of LTP. According to leading contemporary theories, the waves will communicate with the mind, which is where the painfulness is experienced. The material brain and immaterial mind are therefore separate and we can no longer attribute painfulness solely to the activities of the brain. This is a radical departure from the contemporary view of brain functions and supports Cartesian Dualism. Consequently, consciousness and higher mental functions cannot be duplicated by mimicking the activities of the brain.