Evidence for an all-or-none perceptual response: single-trial analyses of magnetoencephalography signals indicate an abrupt transition between visual perception and its absence.

Whether consciousness is all-or-none or graded remains debated. In a magnetoencephalography (MEG) study using sub-threshold, threshold, and supra-threshold duration inputs, averaged evoked responses showed a gradual increase in amplitude with increasing perceptual strength. However, single-trial analyses demonstrated that stimulus perception correlated with an all-or-none response, the temporal precision of which increased systematically as perception transitioned from ambiguous to robust states. Due to poor signal-to-noise resolution, whether perception-related responses were invariant in amplitude could not be unambiguously demonstrated. The findings strongly suggest that visual perception of simple stimuli is associated with an all-or-none cortical-evoked response whose temporal precision varies with perceptual strength.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Whether consciousness is an all-or-none or graded phenomenon is an area of inquiry that has received considerable interest in neuroscience and is as of yet, still debated. In this magnetoencephalography (MEG) study we used a single stimulus paradigm with sub-threshold, threshold and supra-threshold duration inputs to assess whether stimulus perception is continuous with or abruptly differentiated from unconscious stimulus processing in the brain. By grouping epochs according to stimulus identification accuracy and exposure duration, we were able to investigate whether a high-amplitude perception-related cortical event was (1) only evoked for conditions where perception was most probable, (2) had invariant amplitude once evoked and (3) was largely absent for conditions where perception was least probable (criteria satisfying an all-on-none hypothesis). We found that averaged evoked responses showed a gradual increase in amplitude with increasing perceptual strength. However, single-trial analyses demonstrated that stimulus perception was correlated with an all-or-none response, the temporal precision of which increased systematically as perception transitioned from ambiguous to robust states. Due to poor signal-to-noise resolution of single-trial data, whether perception-related responses, whenever present, were invariant in amplitude could not be unambiguously demonstrated. However, our findings strongly suggest that visual perception of simple stimuli is associated with an all-or-none cortical-evoked response the temporal precision of which varies as a function of perceptual strength.