Skip to content

Physiology of Dreaming

C Timo‐Iaria, Angela C. Valle

Sleep Science June 1, 2009 DOI: 10.1055/s-0046-1820477 (opens in new tab)

Study at a glance

AI-extracted from the abstract
Characteristics Review Peer reviewed
Topics Dreaming
Key findings Argues that Aristotle's observations of animal movements during sleep established a link between such movements and dreaming, a concept that persists in modern research. The text proposes that muscle movements during sleep are a reliable indicator of dreaming in humans and other animals, and that most dreams are related to events of the previous day.

Abstract

Dreaming has been a subject of cogitation since remote Antiquity. In ancient Greece, Socrates, Plato and Aristotle discussed about the meaning of dreams, concluding that the prevailing mistic and mythic concepts about them were incorrect. Instead, they thought that dreams were not provoked by spirits, ghosts or gods, which took over the mind to express themselves through dreaming. Aristotle[ 1 ], who had carefully observed several animal species while asleep, noticed that movements of several of their body parts were quite similar to those performed by humans during dreaming. Some of his statements, hereby reproduced in a simplified form from his book on sleep and dreams, briefly illustrate his contribution to the study of this subject: "All creatures that have four limbs and are sanguine (mammals) display signs that they dream while asleep. It seems that not only humans but also dogs, cows, sheep and goats and the entire family of four-legged viviparous animals do dream." "As to the oviparous creatures, it is obvious that they sleep but it is impossible to state that they dream. The same holds true for animals that live in water, such as fishes, molusks, crustacea and other similar animals; it is impossible to invoke as a proof that they do sleep the shutting of their eyes, inasmuch as they do not have eyelids but it is obvious that they periodically do rest, immobile, what perhaps does explain why at night their predators attack them heavily and devour them. When they sleep, fishes keep quiet, with no apparent movements, and then they can be easily fished with a hand." "Insects are also creatures that do sleep, so much so that they can be seen resting with no movements whatsoever. This is specially true as to bees, that at night do interrupt their hum, "even if they are exposed to the light of a lantern". "Dreams are not ghosts (phantasmata), since they are closely related to the events of the previous day". In Greece dreams were called oneiros , a word that originated the adjective oniric but that meant not exactly what was dreamed about neither the dreaming process, which was not rated as something important, but the phantasmata , i.e. the apparitions. As a prevailing concept even today, dreams were considered premonitory, messages from the dead and mystical warnings. Herodotus, in his Histories , the first textbook on History ever written, tells that the Persian King Xerxes dreamed quite often about the war he was about to fight against Athens. He properly related such dreams to his concern with that important war. His personal oracle, however, disagreed and convinced him that his dreams were warnings from the gods. Xerxes, in fact, had discovered an important aspect of dreams but his oracle discarded such an explanation, in favor of the mystic one. In the past, most civilizations boasted having wise people who could tell the meaning of dreams if conveniently paid for that, a fancy profession that still has its counterparts in modern nations. Psychoanalysis considers dreams as an important window to the unconscious world, what makes dream interpretation a crucial factor in psychonalytic diagnosis and treatment. However, psychoanalysts take into account only a few dreams that are occasionally recalled, despite the fact that we dream four or five episodes every night, what means that the fraction of dreams we can is a of what we in fact do as Psychoanalysis also considers dreams as the of this is true as to only a few dreams, several that most dreams are closely related to the events of the previous as Aristotle had Socrates, Aristotle and were to the prevailing of the that mystic and to the of dreams as their However, they that the dreams were by the and who discovered that the mind is in the not in the that dreams were originated in the the the first of in his book for the of the of sleep and despite his of dreams, by of the of that the dreams with a those with an and those in which the or even in fact, that only could be as an oniric the of the a who in and was a and that and at night, which he to the in by then the of of the entire and in the and in the that had been by and that important into and this of the also about the in as considered dreams or to but could not to their The ancient to dreaming but also considered them the several and to the and meaning of in his book of , in with movements as a of dreams, and in and its , also took the movements of and during sleep as a of important of in his book in and , in and several in the ], that at and do a concept that still despite which most that on sleep still that dreaming is the of the several on oniric of the who the that the ancient of the several at night his during sleep and that their movements while were related to their dreams, as Aristotle had The in an important, the of , the of people they parts of the body during sleep and them to their discovered that most dreams during the of the night and that of them are closely related to the events the important were by the of which was was in the of several of dreams as related to their do not from modern of the same in in his book and of a no and with dreams, which that the study of dreams not during the of the as is for on sleep was the of into dreams, in his book that the and the movements in humans and other animals during sleep it is to the of dreaming and even to the dream as this is we the in a in that the to humans by the In a who was a to his study and the in 1 The of the sleep as as is is quite in this The first sleep its the and their to a that has of sleep, as by in and through the of to an was by a and as on a In in of in from 1 the first of the despite the of dreaming was but In for ], and of that what is to as of dreaming In observed that in humans during sleep at of which is the of a sleep that also in is during or sleep but it is not to In in sleep has also been and was to that sleep, was However, is the to its the of an The that to the are for the and of the that during It is that during sleep the an in which is not by but to that the of the during In of sleep in by that he considered as a of sleep and in a of by to an in with a in of the in were in the of and ], in which they the of by but to with a and a in the of the study of sleep in that during the movements, the why such has been the of and the same in it sleep , inasmuch as the of this in humans that of the sleep , which we in humans is the of this However, the of dreams during this it be oniric of sleep by it to in of the and to and or also or has been of the for the of the not only sleep but also the of dreaming. despite the of of the past, most that with sleep and by and a do not the that animals do dream. we are convinced that at and do As a of fact, of dreaming have been in and in humans dream every night, signs of dreaming during sleep has been in and but the only in of an movements, and to In only at a be in In have oniric during sleep, similar to what we in as sleep as is a dream is a that during sleep it in sleep it during the The of dreams As in ], or from but is by that be but those that during As it has to be so that the which it be and as a that the from the a is to and and only it can be by means of the The of such is a dream As a dream a that we an oniric of that a dream and the oniric in of such as a of the from it has been as of to of the its with the of such is the dream. of the oniric from In humans a dream be and its can be of dreams is much and the is much is during sleep and the of sleep, and are by a and has been the of sleep in and their This that dream in from to of was and that the of the dream of in the of that they do not dream but this is inasmuch as at this have a and their about dreams are to such a not their the and much of the dream as be on dream do not that dreaming in to and but also to a that dreaming is a such as but it is It is most an in and if dreaming has a it a similar in the and in as In animals the dreams is impossible a dream can be in humans and other species by its and as be as other during of and The are and movements during a if it during a dream during sleep not only movements are to the dream but also the is much The , that are of and most as are during a as they are during The for such is that the is so much so that of the to the be it or or a of which is to the by the through such as in and When a dream is a and events be In however, a of and what also during an if they are In such a the a that the in to it is dead and to a that is in of of the of the which we to as , that express the of sleep in several of the the during which most oniric the or sleep is the during this in in humans and other In are also but in the be In only the in the and in the as of the that can be with movements and in and as an in humans such of dreams can be related to their in animals it is to with a of not only the and the of but the of as with such animals are and be in the of dreaming The of dreams are as to the dream a dream the during an dream the and are When a dream has a the and other do and if the dream is several do the by the dreams such movements are not with the dream ], as be as a they can be related to the sleep of a and that and of sleep a few the previous light of the but in the from the by of the In the movements while their and the eyes, that the of the that the movements were to the of in which is the of the is a factor of and a is the of the is the the is the which the are the The is the of the is the which is to a of the or the is the of the by the it is to if the is or movements during dreaming are as of which can be as to movements performed as a of the movements of the dreamed of and however, that in movements during sleep are in that the to to of the to the of the of movements during with movements in and however, that movements are but in other they to be of the The movements be related to the dream as such also to but it be into that originated by a dream is we during a what does not to the of we dream we are the from in such quite that they are not to In and in in with in and that oniric movements be to or the not to as by and movements in humans is and is in of As be in that are movements during sleep over the of of movements during dreams, to the dream of that be in those in and in people but such a is to be movements in are to a quite is so much so that if we a we the to the of the to its even if is in of does and that most dreams in humans have a the why movements in of or as of In is the and their are to the of at It is not that during dreaming in and most of their dreams and As movements, the of movements does the of the the animal is to the of an that is at a movements are to at the is such movements are to at as during have of the and during of such was to during sleep, what to its in dreaming In and is dreams as from their In during ], as in This dreams, as has been in In we have movements in sleep, which we to the of dreams of sleep of a The is the that movements, a movements are with the movements the and a which is of a dream with movements dreams with In humans they that of the dreams a of but in people with a the of such dreams to over as from the dreams and the events in the previous in which are and with movements, the and the are in but they as of a dream their be in what in movements, or or which does not in oniric movements, which in or not with the that are dreamed The dream and the oniric movements was first by who and movements and related them to what was dreamed performed during the such also the of dreams as related to their In the first of dreams the several also the of 1 the of of such dreaming episodes from as do not tell their dreams, we the of dreams by the of movements the animals The in 1 a of the dream as related to their is that in are to those by in which was as the of the of by other It be that, the dream in humans with events of the previous in that of the dreams were closely related to such The why we dream we are we do not of the and or we dream we are to we do not is that in the of in the the and do not the movements to However, we still do not why most are while a few are but and movements The of could be but we why it is to this we are to movements in humans and animals and the of we that such movements in and in animals are of dreaming it is impossible to explain the and the movements that of animals during of the of as a fraction of the to their or of the dream to their or of the of 1 1 1 1 the of the of during sleep that while the animal sleep, this was only as to its during However, during sleep it was for most of the the , as we to is also during this of In are also during it is since and that the to a during sleep is much the to during It seems that a the to of is still and be in to which of and are to humans and during It is that even be in an during sleep if they are light be It is that the of an does not people who live in the of but a light be to as as the by an the the The of by in the during sleep is by of their This is to an to which that or are on the during In during movements related to dreams such is by of to in the is during and be the of the of in In the at the first in the and in the and as a of in the are the an to the that is provoked not by the but by to its in the is during this of during sleep as in the and and that the in the of the that to the was by and does heavily is by the that sleep and its through the as as through that to the the such an is and during oniric the movements by the dream can be as was in in the animal and with the as if the animal were have that the from the to the are of the in from the to in the a of which through the of the and of also of from of the the and and with in the by means of is a as by it seems that are from the to the that during sleep, in the and the other in the of the the of the the It is to that while over the body are during sleep, is that in the are during during the entire sleep but is during dreaming it is a that has to be in the oniric In sleep is a as movements during movements take the to the it has not been that the are in it is to that their such sleep The for the sleep and of movements, is not in is in the and to a a in it to of from this of during sleep as a of is not movements to during is of As is as a of and The are for to inasmuch as the by the to of the as much as the of the body as a are of that are to in to the and and and and are to the of to the and during the of the that and a and that are to and and of the of the are of as as of in and and several other are and of Some have not been to in and during but are that is as as of is also and the of such a of and is the of the during this of In that to such a the from and that from to a in an inasmuch as the of such during sleep, to It is not if such a does in if it what is we can that it is the of the that that during of sleep of a the in the and in the is by sleep to sleep with movements of the but movements while during oniric however, in and do that are closely related to the dream that is such in are not to it to but during a to In people with such a their In 1 or movements an in from to is the during resting in this with the of to 1 or the of The and movements be related to the that are in the the oniric the of the dream In is during the of oniric as and that, in the during is in sleep it to and during movements that oniric it When the the for a and be as as similar to that during such do not that and during however, it is that and related to the which are most to the oniric that in the to as as the to The also a of that be related to dreaming with are quite as to the of and during oniric the are also is in but it is that body to dreaming inasmuch as of are while dreaming is a the other a in and in but during dreaming the and which is related to the of the oniric as is the during The that from is during but are no in while dreaming is In humans the during sleep are as the of the by in humans oniric is as movements, what is to as the movements are in the by that on However, oniric are also as and movements, as as and limbs as In and movements are by in the in the body and in the they are as and In can be from the In we similar in the as related to dreams, as have been in of the in to of the in the and in the of the during The of a the which is of a of by the It is for that are for the of dreaming but such is not of dreaming are the the the and the of oniric in humans as as in other The are of in such and signs of oniric are to that a dream is that most dreams in are related to not to that in the of this animal species also be as signs of dreaming In sleep also as but in the and as in and discovered by and in ], were by ], who they are related to were also in during and were in to be related to in as by the to and of in during oniric as in ], and in a of oniric is as a in and with a of an of and sleep and oniric of a This is a in which a and oniric movements is quite the first the oniric as and movements, at a It is then by a in which to and no movements are in the In the a of and movements do in with a in and of are and and movements oniric the from to and then oniric , and , , , , , , , in oniric in a as movements and a in in are the and movements are only during the of the oniric the first of the sleep sleep and a of through a to a but or to a but dreaming in , , and , four , , , as and movements, movements are The in is in the The of the movements to the of similar to what during the is the with its movements are as of the , , , in the and , and , and movements, and 1 the of in it seems they at but the of is as a of a during the movements the of the and as with the oniric and that of that in the to be crucial for of the in of in in and and in of a during a oniric to the When the oniric of the to of the same in It is that during a quite and in in and then to at a in of the we in by carefully their while a dream is on as during is the of of that interrupt or on that is over the in humans and in the of and we it to be a of through be as a of a of during or during dreaming. In fact, it does movements are as such in are with but which is to a of is to In humans it has been that not only but also in such as and ], that are that in the that and sleep and their their and in with and of movements The of is the why such in In fact, the of in is with the in it is to the of or the during sleep in are in and in the as as with the As in ], of the of several of the that the be The of is as as in the of are with those in the what to a in and in the is in the are to those in the is and the of that in such from other in the is thought to the of and is to to the and the we that closely with those in the in for the in several of the during and of sleep of a the in in a of in and of , of the The to or the other is not inasmuch as it on the of the in the The of are in the and and , and to and only do in the during sleep but also and are in this in sleep, as in In fact, the of and sleep, sleep, in the a is with the to the only of is that the is in of the of of is on the When of the a it the to the This from the entire the as by the with the that tells it the is the so that the can the this is it is no that the of and sleep are in the by means of the during ], which be related to of during dreaming. In the had also from of in the which be related to of in oniric as However, of the the of during but the seems to be in such the does not to be from of related to the body in during that that the animals in the the also an to during sleep, in to sleep episodes the the other that were during the not the in The that the they was in but such that during dreaming is to a dreaming against during sleep, what is in to This in however, still from inasmuch as are several in the It be to explain the by that dreams are originated in and closely related to events of dreaming of sleep is but not that of dreaming. In we that of a The of this the and with sleep in The previous of is the with sleep In sleep to the of and then of sleep, during which movements In several of the at the to sleep still the sleep can be provoked by in the movements, and are still the the and sleep keep but In this body is not and the animal has to be at if body in to is the of sleep for sleep to about of at it of the what has not been so When the is the and the in the is The of is to study the of the , that the It however, been with a in sleep In movements do and are the and his important in this ], that the that the of oniric such as and movements, that the be and and are in to the the that oniric movements while are through of their The has been to no in the movements that dreaming. It is not why and the of is by the that such movements but this a for the of the and the of The movements that during sleep are to and during the same of sleep and to have the same is that movements are the of the but does not with this from the movements by to which to as the in the that movements during that the in the are in the oniric movements but they do not that such them. be only in of the that such of several dreaming in In an on this a of dreaming in with or The in this are the and are not to which be by the fact that is in the during and the of dreams with are on the can be The meaning of dreams This is for the most about dreaming. are to account for the of dreams but it is still a of why and what for we dream. In fact, we why we dream. and have about that but the to be of a or an Some true this we only on a few As by four of the of that dreams, such as or dreams, were only a of or As this be as a of something that we be to do for are still by a of the as premonitory, them the of that something important that has is the that dreams, in sleep in with several that this is a few against such a for that the in to a of sleep and dreaming in of the that despite the of sleep provoked by neither and and are a in favor of the from the study of a in This ], to a in the of a of in the and its is thought to a of to has been to the of a ], and has been to the of and other In is in several or