Dissolving the Combination Problem: Second-Order Distinction and the Genesis of New Subjects

Abstract

Panpsychism promises to escape the puzzle of consciousness emerging from wholly experience-less matter by admitting experience at reality's most fundamental layer, but it inherits an unfinished difficulty of its own: the combination problem, how the aggregation of micro-experiences yields a single, unified macro-experience. Building on an ontological framework formulated elsewhere, this paper argues that relation itself is generative of being: when two independent foci of experience intersect under precise, specifiable conditions, a new focus with its own intrinsic aspect is born, without the prior components dissolving. Three criteria, lock of the collapse direction, independence with path memory, and preservation of boundary phase-alignment, distinguish this genesis from mere addition and from full fusion, and hold the framework accountable against Coleman, Goff, Strawson, and Mørch. The framework generates testable predictions and shows that the combination problem, in its classical formulation, admits a principled dissolution rather than merely a new answer.