The New Clarity: Awakening in the Post-Truth Era

The late 2010s saw a perceived post-truth crisis fueled by social media, fragmenting liberal democracy into antagonistic epistemic bubbles. Yet the same online movements driving this crisis became captivated by the idea of waking from a false reality to absolute Truth, from new spiritual fascinations with mystical clarity to far-right notions of a Great Awakening and red-pilling. This article argues that this 'New Clarity' represents the cutting edge of the post-truth predicament, intensifying postmodern cynicism and irony while breaking with them through new political-epistemic radicalisms.

Study at a glance

Abstract

Abstract:In the wake of Trump and Brexit, the late 2010s gave rise to an ambient sense of a post-truth crisis. It signals the social media fuelled breakdown of liberal democracy and its 'fourth estate' into fragmented and mutually antagonising epistemic media bubbles. Yet at the same time, the new online political movements driving this crisis became enthralled with the radical sense of waking up from a false reality to absolute Truth, ranging from new (con)spiritual fascinations with mystical clarity to far-right ideas about a Great Awakening and red-pilling. This article tries to make sense of this strange resurgence of 'awakening' and the experience of radical epistemic clarity from within post-truth culture. We argue that what we refer to as the New Clarity represents the bleeding edge of our current post-truth predicament, which at once intensifies 'postmodern' sentiments of cynicism, irony and play and breaks with them in the form of new political-epistemic radicalisms. To draw out this paradoxical relationship between post-truth and the New Clarity, we survey three historical dimensions of postmodernism as theorised by Lyotard and others at the closing of the 20th century, namely: cynicism and the crisis of critique, new spiritualities and authoritarian conspiracism, and the spiralling dialectic between neoliberalism and populism. Breaking down these dimensions to understand the New Clarity, we take the QAnon conspiracy movement as embodying its paradoxical logic. Doing so we offer a critical heuristic for charting the rise of new conspiratorial and spiritual Awakenings today.