A systematic review of 21 randomized controlled trials of psilocybin- and MDMA-assisted therapies (total 1034 participants) found that participant samples lack diversity. Gender was always reported, race or ethnicity in 76% of trials, and socioeconomic status in 57%. Sexual orientation (9.5%) and immigration status (4.8%) were rarely reported; no study reported gender identity. Compared to the US population and non-psychedelic clinical trials, Black/African-American participants (2.2%) and Hispanic/Latino participants (7.2%) were significantly underrepresented. MDMA trials enrolled more diverse samples than psilocybin trials. Analyses of treatment effects by demographic variables were virtually absent. The findings indicate a need for inclusive recruitment and rigorous reporting to improve generalizability.
Limited participant diversity in mental health intervention research perpetuates health disparities, a concern especially relevant to psychedelic-assisted psychotherapy (PAT). This systematic review of 21 randomized controlled trials of psilocybin- and MDMA-assisted therapies (total 1,034 participants) found that gender (100%) and race or ethnicity (76%) were frequently reported, while socioeconomic status was sometimes reported (57%) using varied measures. Sexual orientation (9.5%) and immigration status (4.8%) were rarely reported, and no studies reported gender identity. Black/African-American (12.2%) and Hispanic/Latino (7.2%) participants were significantly underrepresented compared to the US population and non-psychedelic clinical trials. MDMA trials enrolled more diverse samples than psilocybin trials. Analyses of treatment effects by sociodemographic variables were virtually nonexistent, highlighting the need for inclusive recruitment and rigorous reporting to improve generalizability.