A Guide to Wilberland: Some Common Misunderstandings of the Critics of Ken Wilber and His Work on Transpersonal Theory Prior to 1995
Robert M. Fisher
Journal of Humanistic Psychology October 1, 1997 DOI: 10.1177/00221678970374005 (opens in new tab)
Study at a glance
AI-extracted from the abstract| Characteristics | Theoretical or philosophical paper Peer reviewed |
|---|---|
| Key points | Argues that critiques of Ken Wilber's transpersonal theory are often unsubstantiated and polemical, contrary to his unifying intentions. Proposes that Wilber's critical style, while sometimes arrogant, does not justify the critics' interpretations, and offers hypotheses for further study of the conflict. |
Abstract
This article substantiates the importance of Ken Wilber and his work on transpersonal theory to the psychology and spirituality of human development over the past 23 years. Wilber and his work, prior to 1995, continue to attract ardent controversy, particularly outside of the field of transpersonal psychology. The focus of this article is directed to the identification of a few common pervasive misunderstandings based on recent critiques from writers in psychology. Although Wilber's critical style is at times unnecessarily arrogant, the evidence indicates that the critics' interpretations are not often substantiated and tend to become explicitly or implicitly polemical. This trend is the opposite effect of Wilber's stated intentions of his unifying spectrum psychology. This article is divided into three parts: First is Wilber's actual intentions; second, his major theses; and third, his critical style, with a number of summary hypotheses provided for further study to explain the conflicts between Wilber and his critics.
Citations in the library
Cites 12
- Paths beyond Ego: The Transpersonal Vision Buddhist-Christian Studies 1995
- Two Humanistic Psychologies? A Response Journal of Humanistic Psychology April 1, 1989
- Two Patterns of Transcendence Journal of Humanistic Psychology July 1, 1990
- God Is So Damn Boring Journal of Humanistic Psychology October 1, 1989
- Transpersonal phenomenology: The corporeal schema. The Humanistic Psychologist 1988
and 7 more in the library