Skip to content

Hallucinations and aberrant perceptions are prevalent among the young healthy adult population

S. García-Ptacek, D. García Azorín, R. Sanchez Salmador, M.L. Cuadrado, J. Porta-Etessam

Neurología (English Edition) May 4, 2019 DOI: 10.1016/j.nrleng.2012.02.002 (opens in new tab)

Study at a glance

AI-extracted from the abstract
Characteristics Observational study Peer reviewed
Sample size 134
Population Third to sixth year medical students at Universidad Complutense de Madrid completing clinical rotations at Hospital Clínico San Carlos
Key findings Among 134 medical students, 54 completed interviews; 22.2% reported visual phenomena and 64.8% auditory phenomena, with 38.8% hearing the phone or doorbell without it ringing. All had good insight and none had psychotic symptoms, suggesting such perceptions are frequent and non-pathological in healthy young adults.

Abstract

Introduction: Hallucinations are frequent in clinical practice, with an incidence of up to 38.7% in the general population. We aim to determine the prevalence of hallucinations among healthy young adults in our environment. Subjects and

Methods: We designed an observational study, using as subjects, third to sixth year medical students of the Universidad Complutense de Madrid who complete clinical rotations in the Hospital Clínico San Carlos. After a screening questionnaire, an individual interview was conducted via telephone or e-mail for those students who reported hallucinations. We obtained clinical and epidemiological data through a semi-structured clinical interview performed by a third year neurology resident.

Results: N = 134 (average age was 22.1 years; 77.6% were women). 74 respondents answered affirmatively to one or more screening questions, and 54 completed the follow-up interview. 22.2% described visual phenomena and 64.8%, auditory. The majority reported sleep-related experiences and auditory perceptions related to hyper vigilance, such as hearing the telephone or the doorbell ring when in fact it had not (38.8%). All subjects had good insight and none had psychotic symptoms. Two cases were associated with substance abuse.

Conclusions: Hallucinations are frequent among the general population. Traditionally, auditory phenomena have been associated with psychotic pathology, and other studies show a low population incidence (0.6%). However, in our sample, short auditory perceptions with immediate insight were frequent and not pathological. Resumen: Introducción: Las alucinaciones son frecuentes en la práctica clínica y presentan una incidencia poblacional de hasta el 38.7%. El objetivo del estudio es determinar la prevalencia de percepciones aberrantes entre jóvenes sanos de nuestro entorno. Sujetos y Métodos: Estudio observacional entre estudiantes de 3.° a 6.° curso de Medicina de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid que realizan prácticas en el Hospital Clínico San Carlos. Tras una encuesta de cribado, se realizó una entrevista individual a aquellos sujetos que presentaban percepciones aberrantes. Recogimos datos epidemiológicos mediante anamnesis semi-estructurada administrada por una residente de tercer año de Neurología. Resultados: N = 134 (edad media 22.1 años, 77.6% mujeres). 74 respondedores contestaron afirmativamente a alguna de las preguntas de screening y 54 completaron la entrevista. El 22.2% presentó fenómenos visuales y el 64.8% auditivos. La mayoría describieron fenómenos asociados al sueño y percepciones auditivas como oír el teléfono o el timbre de la puerta sin que hubieran sonado (38.8%). Todos presentaron crítica de los episodios y ninguno refirió síntomas psicóticos. Dos casos se asociaron a tóxicos. Conclusiones: Las percepciones aberrantes son muy frecuentes entre la población general. Clásicamente, se asocian los fenómenos auditivos a patología psicótica, y otros estudios dan una incidencia poblacional baja (0.6%). Sin embargo, en nuestra serie las percepciones auditivas de corta duración y con crítica inmediata eran frecuentes y no se asociaban a patología. Keywords: Hallucinations, Aberrant perceptions, Non-clinical population, Hypnagogic and hypnopompic hallucinations, Auditory hallucinations, Palabras clave: Alucinaciones, Percepciones aberrantes, Población general, Alucinaciones hipnagógicas e hipnopómpicas, Alucinaciones auditivas